Tuesday, May 25, 2010
Global Crisis
The Global Economic Crisis,
The Great Depression of the XXI Century
Global Research, May 25, 2010
The following text is the Preface of The Global Economic Crisis. The Great Depression of the XXI Century, Michel Chossudovsky and Andrew Gavin Marshall (Editors), Montreal, Global Research, 2010, which is to be launched in late May.
Each of the authors in this timely collection digs beneath the gilded surface to reveal a complex web of deceit and media distortion which serves to conceal the workings of the global economic system and its devastating impacts on people's lives.
The complex causes as well as the devastating consequences of the economic crisis are carefully scrutinized with contributions from Ellen Brown, Tom Burghardt, Michel Chossudovsky, Richard C. Cook, Shamus Cooke, John Bellamy Foster, Michael Hudson, Tanya Cariina Hsu, Fred Magdoff, Andrew Gavin Marshall, James Petras, Peter Phillips, Peter Dale Scott, Bill Van Auken, Claudia von Werlhof and Mike Whitney.
Despite the diversity of viewpoints and perspectives presented within this volume, all of the contributors ultimately come to the same conclusion: humanity is at the crossroads of the most serious economic and social crisis in modern history.
In all major regions of the world, the economic recession is deep-seated, resulting in mass unemployment, the collapse of state social programs and the impoverishment of millions of people. The economic crisis is accompanied by a worldwide process of militarization, a "war without borders" led by the United States of America and its NATO allies. The conduct of the Pentagon’s "long war" is intimately related to the restructuring of the global economy.
We are not dealing with a narrowly defined economic crisis or recession. The global financial architecture sustains strategic and national security objectives. In turn, the U.S.-NATO military agenda serves to endorse a powerful business elite which relentlessly overshadows and undermines the functions of civilian government.
This book takes the reader through the corridors of the Federal Reserve and the Council on Foreign Relations, behind closed doors at the Bank for International Settlements, into the plush corporate boardrooms on Wall Street where far-reaching financial transactions are routinely undertaken from computer terminals linked up to major stock markets, at the touch of a mouse button.
Each of the authors in this collection digs beneath the gilded surface to reveal a complex web of deceit and media distortion which serves to conceal the workings of the global economic system and its devastating impacts on people’s lives. Our analysis focuses on the role of powerful economic and political actors in an environment wrought by corruption, financial manipulation and fraud.
Despite the diversity of viewpoints and perspectives presented within this volume, all of the contributors ultimately come to the same conclusion: humanity is at the crossroads of the most serious economic and social crisis in modern history.
The meltdown of financial markets in 2008-2009 was the result of institutionalized fraud and financial manipulation. The "bank bailouts" were implemented on the instructions of Wall Street, leading to the largest transfer of money wealth in recorded history, while simultaneously creating an insurmountable public debt.
With the worldwide deterioration of living standards and plummeting consumer spending, the entire structure of international commodity trade is potentially in jeopardy. The payments system of money transactions is in disarray. Following the collapse of employment, the payment of wages is disrupted, which in turn triggers a downfall in expenditures on necessary consumer goods and services. This dramatic plunge in purchasing power backfires on the productive system, resulting in a string of layoffs, plant closures and bankruptcies. Exacerbated by the freeze on credit, the decline in consumer demand contributes to the demobilization of human and material resources.
This process of economic decline is cumulative. All categories of the labor force are affected. Payments of wages are no longer implemented, credit is disrupted and capital investments are at a standstill. Meanwhile, in Western countries, the "social safety net" inherited from the welfare state, which protects the unemployed during an economic downturn, is also in jeopardy.
The Myth of Economic Recovery
The existence of a "Great Depression" on the scale of the 1930s, while often acknowledged, is overshadowed by an unbending consensus: "The economy is on the road to recovery".
While there is talk of an economic renewal, Wall Street commentators have persistently and intentionally overlooked the fact that the financial meltdown is not simply composed of one bubble – the housing real estate bubble – which has already burst. In fact, the crisis has many bubbles, all of which dwarf the housing bubble burst of 2008.
Although there is no fundamental disagreement among mainstream analysts on the occurrence of an economic recovery, there is heated debate as to when it will occur, whether in the next quarter, or in the third quarter of next year, etc. Already in early 2010, the "recovery" of the U.S. economy had been predicted and confirmed through a carefully worded barrage of media disinformation. Meanwhile, the social plight of increased unemployment in America has been scrupulously camouflaged. Economists view bankruptcy as a microeconomic phenomenon.
The media reports on bankruptcies, while revealing local-level realities affecting one or more factories, fail to provide an overall picture of what is happening at the national and international levels. When all these simultaneous plant closures in towns and cities across the land are added together, a very different picture emerges: entire sectors of a national economy are closing down.
Public opinion continues to be misled as to the causes and consequences of the economic crisis, not to mention the policy solutions. People are led to believe that the economy has a logic of its own which depends on the free interplay of market forces, and that powerful financial actors, who pull the strings in the corporate boardrooms, could not, under any circumstances, have willfully influenced the course of economic events.
The relentless and fraudulent appropriation of wealth is upheld as an integral part of "the American dream", as a means to spreading the benefits of economic growth. As conveyed by Michael Hudson, the myth becomes entrenched that "without wealth at the top, there would be nothing to trickle down." Such flawed logic of the business cycle overshadows an understanding of the structural and historical origins of the global economic crisis.
Financial Fraud
Media disinformation largely serves the interests of a handful of global banks and institutional speculators which use their command over financial and commodity markets to amass vast amounts of money wealth. The corridors of the state are controlled by the corporate establishment including the speculators. Meanwhile, the "bank bailouts", presented to the public as a requisite for economic recovery, have facilitated and legitimized a further process of appropriation of wealth.
Vast amounts of money wealth are acquired through market manipulation. Often referred to as "deregulation", the financial apparatus has developed sophisticated instruments of outright manipulation and deceit. With inside information and foreknowledge, major financial actors, using the instruments of speculative trade, have the ability to fiddle and rig market movements to their advantage, precipitate the collapse of a competitor and wreck havoc in the economies of developing countries. These tools of manipulation have become an integral part of the financial architecture; they are embedded in the system.
The Failure of Mainstream Economics
The economics profession, particularly in the universities, rarely addresses the actual "real world" functioning of markets. Theoretical constructs centered on mathematical models serve to represent an abstract, fictional world in which individuals are equal. There is no theoretical distinction between workers, consumers or corporations, all of which are referred to as "individual traders". No single individual has the power or ability to influence the market, nor can there be any conflict between workers and capitalists within this abstract world.
By failing to examine the interplay of powerful economic actors in the "real life" economy, the processes of market rigging, financial manipulation and fraud are overlooked. The concentration and centralization of economic decision-making, the role of the financial elites, the economic thinks tanks, the corporate boardrooms: none of these issues are examined in the universities’ economics programs. The theoretical construct is dysfunctional; it cannot be used to provide an understanding of the economic crisis.
Economic science is an ideological construct which serves to camouflage and justify the New World Order. A set of dogmatic postulates serves to uphold free market capitalism by denying the existence of social inequality and the profit-driven nature of the system is denied. The role of powerful economic actors and how these actors are able to influence the workings of financial and commodity markets is not a matter of concern for the discipline’s theoreticians. The powers of market manipulation which serve to appropriate vast amounts of money wealth are rarely addressed. And when they are acknowledged, they are considered to belong to the realm of sociology or political science.
This means that the policy and institutional framework behind this global economic system, which has been shaped in the course of the last thirty years, is rarely analyzed by mainstream economists. It follows that economics as a discipline, with some exceptions, has not provided the analysis required to comprehend the economic crisis. In fact, its main free market postulates deny the existence of a crisis. The focus of neoclassical economics is on equilibrium, disequilibrium and "market correction" or "adjustment" through the market mechanism, as a means to putting the economy back "onto the path of self-sustained growth".
Poverty and Social Inequality
The global political economy is a system that enriches the very few at the expense of the vast majority. The global economic crisis has contributed to widening social inequalities both within and between countries. Under global capitalism, mounting poverty is not the result of a scarcity or a lack of human and material resources. Quite the opposite holds true: the economic depression is marked by a process of disengagement of human resources and physical capital. People’s lives are destroyed. The economic crisis is deep-seated.
The structures of social inequality have, quite deliberately, been reinforced, leading not only to a generalized process of impoverishment but also to the demise of the middle and upper middle income groups.
Middle class consumerism, on which this unruly model of capitalist development is based, is also threatened. Bankruptcies have hit several of the most vibrant sectors of the consumer economy. The middle classes in the West have, for several decades, been subjected to the erosion of their material wealth. While the middle class exists in theory, it is a class built and sustained by household debt.
The wealthy rather than the middle class are rapidly becoming the consuming class, leading to the relentless growth of the luxury goods economy. Moreover, with the drying up of the middle class markets for manufactured goods, a central and decisive shift in the structure of economic growth has occurred. With the demise of the civilian economy, the development of America’s war economy, supported by a whopping near-trillion dollar defense budget, has reached new heights. As stock markets tumble and the recession unfolds, the advanced weapons industries, the military and national security contractors and the up-and-coming mercenary companies (among others) have experienced a thriving and booming growth of their various activities.
War and the Economic Crisis
War is inextricably linked to the impoverishment of people at home and around the world. Militarization and the economic crisis are intimately related. The provision of essential goods and services to meet basic human needs has been replaced by a profit-driven "killing machine" in support of America’s "Global War on Terror". The poor are made to fight the poor. Yet war enriches the upper class, which controls industry, the military, oil and banking. In a war economy, death is good for business, poverty is good for society, and power is good for politics. Western nations, particularly the United States, spend hundreds of billions of dollars a year to murder innocent people in far-away impoverished nations, while the people at home suffer the disparities of poverty, class, gender and racial divides.
An outright "economic war" resulting in unemployment, poverty and disease is carried out through the free market. People’s lives are in a freefall and their purchasing power is destroyed. In a very real sense, the last twenty years of global "free market" economy have resulted, through poverty and social destitution, in the lives of millions of people.
Rather than addressing an impending social catastrophe, Western governments, which serve the interests of the economic elites, have installed a "Big Brother" police state, with a mandate to confront and repress all forms of opposition and social dissent.
The economic and social crisis has by no means reached its climax and entire countries, including Greece and Iceland, are at risk. One need only look at the escalation of the Middle East Central Asian war and the U.S.-NATO threats to China, Russia and Iran to witness how war and the economy are intimately related.
Our Analysis in this Book
The contributors to this book reveal the intricacies of global banking and its insidious relationship to the military industrial complex and the oil conglomerates. The book presents an inter- disciplinary and multi-faceted approach, while also conveying an understanding of the historical and institutional dimensions. The complex relations of the economic crisis to war, empire and worldwide poverty are highlighted. This crisis has a truly global reach and repercussions that reverberate throughout all nations, across all societies.
In Part I, the overall causes of the global economic crisis as well as the failures of mainstream economics are laid out. Michel Chossudovsky focuses on the history of financial deregulation and speculation. Tanya Cariina Hsu analyzes the role of the American Empire and its relationship to the economic crisis. John Bellamy Foster and Fred Magdoff undertake a comprehensive review of the political economy of the crisis, explaining the central role of monetary policy. James Petras and Claudia von Werlhof provide a detailed review and critique of neoliberalism, focusing on the economic, political and social repercussions of the "free market" reforms. Shamus Cooke examines the central role of debt, both public and private.
Part II, which includes chapters by Michel Chossudovsky and Peter Phillips, analyzes the rising tide of poverty and social inequality resulting from the Great Depression.
With contributions by Michel Chossudovsky, Peter Dale Scott, Michael Hudson, Bill Van Auken, Tom Burghardt and Andrew Gavin Marshall, Part III examines the relationship between the economic crisis, National Security, the U.S.-NATO led war and world government. In this context, as conveyed by Peter Dale Scott, the economic crisis creates social conditions which favor the instatement of martial law.
The focus in Part IV is on the global monetary system, its evolution and its changing role. Andrew Gavin Marshall examines the history of central banking as well as various initiatives to create regional and global currency systems. Ellen Brown focuses on the creation of a global central bank and global currency through the Bank for International Settlements (BIS). Richard C. Cook examines the debt-based monetary system as a system of control and provides a framework for democratizing the monetary system.
Part V focuses on the working of the Shadow Banking System, which triggered the 2008 meltdown of financial markets. The chapters by Mike Whitney and Ellen Brown describe in detail how Wall Street’s Ponzi scheme was used to manipulate the market and transfer billions of dollars into the pockets of the banksters.
We are indebted to the authors for their carefully documented research, incisive analysis, and, foremost, for their unbending commitment to the truth: Tom Burghardt, Ellen Brown, Richard C. Cook, Shamus Cooke, John Bellamy Foster, Michael Hudson, Tanya Cariina Hsu, Fred Magdoff, James Petras, Peter Phillips, Peter Dale Scott, Mike Whitney, Bill Van Auken and Claudia von Werlhof, have provided, with utmost clarity, an understanding of the diverse and complex economic, social and political processes which are affecting the lives of millions of people around the world.
We owe a debt of gratitude to Maja Romano of Global Research Publishers, who relentlessly oversaw and coordinated the editing and production of this book, including the creative front page concept. We wish to thank Andréa Joseph for the careful typesetting of the manuscript and front page graphics. We also extend our thanks and appreciation to Isabelle Goulet, Julie Lévesque and Drew McKevitt for their support in the revision and copyediting of the manuscript.
Wednesday, May 26, 2010
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
Overseas Madoff investors get 100 cents on the dollar back
MADRID — About 720,000 investors outside the United States who lost money to the convicted swindler Bernard L. Madoff have settled with their banks, receiving about $15.5 billion in all, according to law firms representing those victims of the fraud.
The settlements cover about 80 percent of the clients represented by the firms, said Javier Cremades, founder of Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo, a Madrid law firm, who helped organize the global alliance of 60 firms a year ago.
The $15.5 billion figure represents, in theory, 100 percent of the amount clients had invested, Mr. Cremades said, but excludes in almost all cases the bogus paper gains that were listed on investor statements.
Looks like the oversea banks didn't want any discovery on their boo
Originally published May 25, 2010 at 10:58 AM | Page modified May 25, 2010 at 11:13 AM
Written by Jon Talton
Sound Economy:What's causing stock market volatility
Beyond primal greed and fear, the movements of the stock market are often a mystery, whatever comic-book explanation may be given by commentators in the moment. The real causes are usually cloaked by millions of individual investor decisions.
Beyond primal greed and fear, the movements of the stock market are often a mystery, whatever comic-book explanation may be given by commentators in the moment. The real causes are usually cloaked by millions of individual investor decisions.
With Tuesday's swoon on Wall Street, following a worldwide sell-off and days of volatility, fear is definitely in command. What else? Lets run through the suspects.
• North Korea. Definitely. The rogue nation is the crazy uncle in the attic, armed with at least rudimentary nuclear weapons and apparently locked in a power struggle as Kim Jong-il fades. Anything could happen. Worse, this unpredictable and dangerous state is located in the heart of the rising world economy.
• European sovereign debt. Not exactly. Europe has long had what Americans would consider lavish welfare states, big government, outlandishly superb infrastructure, etc. The issue is more complicated. First, the euro is a currency experiment that may not survive the Great Disruption — it's a common monetary policy without a common fiscal or political system. Weak nations (Greece) have the potential to drag down strong ones (Germany). Many investors diversified into the euro and now regret it. Second, the exposure of major banks to complex, opaque bets made on the debt could become subprime redux. Some players are no doubt driving down the euro by profitably betting against it. The global financial system's hyper-interconnectivity is once again akin to the malevolent Skynet in the Terminator movies.
• Flash trading: Yes. The so-called flash crash of May 6, caused or worsened by the computerized trading operation, is still spooking markets. Regulators still don't know the extent of flash trading's role, adding to uncertainty. The Securities and Exchange Commission is investigating whether market makers backed away during the crash, eliminating a crucial backstop to a market plunge. Is this yet another way casino capitalism is pulling swindles?
• Financial reform. Nah. The pending bills have been so watered down that Wall Street has little to fear, which means average Americans have much over which to fret. The too-big-to-fail banks remain. Derivatives rules have been fatally weakened. The shadow banking system, the little-regulated laboratory of crashes and fraud, remains in the shadows. A new Glass-Steagall Act to separate risky investment banking from taxpayer-insured commercial banking was dead on arrival. None of this is to say the big Wall Street institutions wouldn't use the market decline to demonize any attempt at enacting new rules.
• Leverage. Oh, yeah. Unlike classic downs in the business cycle, the Great Recession failed to clean up most of the imbalances that helped cause it. This is especially true of heavy debt loads. Australia is now facing a housing collapse fed by debt that is spreading to its banking system. Sound familiar? America's private and corporate debt loads remain very high by historical standards.
• Rally fatigue. Yes. The fuel for the past year's market rise is largely spent. This includes the hot money using dollars and cheap credit to buy equities, low interest rates, bargain stocks, and the bailout and stimulus. Now the market is overvalued and the real economy is recovering too slowly.
The result: We're uncomfortably close to a double-dip recession. Meanwhile, many average Americans burned in the stock market during the 2000s, might be asking themselves why they rushed back to the casino. Those in deficit panic attack might consider where the world still sees a safe haven: U.S. Treasury securities.
Posted by Moss M.Jacques
Regulation vs. Structural Change
Written by James Kwak
Co-author of The Baseline Scenario and of 13 Bankers
Posted: May 25, 2010 11:01 AM
Robert Reich discusses a theme that I think I've discussed before (and first heard expressed by Ezra Klein):
"The most important thing to know about the 1,500 page financial reform bill passed by the Senate last week -- now on he way to being reconciled with the House bill -- is that it's regulatory. It does nothing to change the structure of Wall Street."
Reich's post weirdly cuts off in the middle on his site, but Mark Thoma has a longer excerpt. In that excerpt, Reich concludes this way:
"The only way to have a lasting effect on industries as large and intransigent as banking and health care is to alter their structure. That was the approach taken to finance by Franklin D. Roosevelt in the 1930s, and by Lyndon Johnson to health care (Medicare) in the 1960s.
"So why has Obama consistently chosen regulation over restructuring? Because restructuring Wall Street or health care would surely elicit firestorms from these industries. Both are politically powerful, and Obama did not want to take them on directly."
I would add that Obama is also a political pragmatist with a strong belief that getting something done is better than nothing. I think that on health care he and the administration probably did the best they could. Remember, they barely got a majority in the House, then barely got sixty votes in the Senate, then barely got a majority in the House again (to pass the revised bill), and public opinion was very divided.
But on financial reform I think they could have gotten more done. First of all, public opinion wanted more; and second, the administration lobbied against some of the most far-reaching changes, such as Kaufman-Brown and Blanche Lincoln's derivatives spinout provision, and Merkley-Levin never got a vote. The whole theater of the administration trying to put the bill into stone before it got much stronger should have been embarrassing to them, but they decided they could take the hit.
I think the explanation for this is some combination of (a) the economic policy guys really think that the financial system we have today is basically fine and just needs a little better oversight and (b) Obama just doesn't care that much and wants to save his political capital (and his support from the financial sector) for other issues, like (hopefully) jobs and climate change.
Here's Thoma's conclusion:
"Structural change is harder than imposing new regulations. The fact that legislators are shying away from the harder to impose types of change out of fear of losing reelection support from the financial industry points to the political power the industry still has, and to the need for structural change to reduce this political (and economic) power. If we cannot muster the political will to make such changes in light of the most devastating financial collapse since the Great Depression, that does not bode well for the future."
Monday, May 24, 2010
One false move in Europe could set off global chain reaction
By Howard Schneider and Neil Irwin
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, May 24, 2010; A01
If the trouble starts -- and it remains an "if" -- the trigger may well be obscure to the concerns of most Americans: a missed budget projection by the Spanish government, the failure of Greece to hit a deficit-reduction target, a drop in Ireland's economic output.
But the knife-edge psychology currently governing global markets has put the future of the U.S. economic recovery in the hands of politicians in an assortment of European capitals. If one or more fail to make the expected progress on cutting budgets, restructuring economies or boosting growth, it could drain confidence in a broad and unsettling way. Credit markets worldwide could lock up and throw the global economy back into recession.
For the average American, that seemingly distant sequence of events could translate into another hit on the 401(k) plan, a lost factory shift if exports to Europe decline and another shock to the banking system that might make it harder to borrow.
"If what happened in Greece were to happen in a large country, it could fundamentally mark our times," Angelos Pangratis, head of the European Union delegation to the United States, said Friday after a panel discussion on the crisis in Greece sponsored by the Greater Washington Board of Trade.
That local economic development boards are sponsoring panels on government debt in Greece is perhaps proof enough that Europe's problems are the world's. That the dominoes can tumble fast was shown Thursday when a new and narrowly drawn stock-trading policy in Germany helped trigger a sell-off on Wall Street.
It marks a change, Barclays Capital chief European economist Julian Callow wrote in a Friday analysis, from a situation in which the bonds of European countries were considered to carry virtually zero risk to a "brave new world" where sovereign default in one of the world's core economic areas is a tangible threat. Bank holdings of European debt are now being studied with the same focus given to holdings of U.S. mortgage-backed securities as the global financial crisis unfolded in 2008 -- and with the same suspicion that problems in one part of the world could wreck others.
The most vulnerable European countries -- Greece, Spain, Portugal and Ireland -- may represent only about 4 percent of world economic activity, but "the debt crisis and its ripple effects are bad news for all corners of the world," said Cornell University economist Eswar Prasad.
The risk of a worst-case scenario is still considered remote. European countries have pledged hundreds of billions of dollars to aid indebted neighbors that run into trouble, and they say they are committed to fixing the continent's larger economic problems. The euro and U.S. markets were both higher Friday after the German Parliament approved a key piece of that support program. A renewed effort by the U.S. Federal Reserve to ensure that European banks have adequate access to dollars has generated little demand -- a sign that a feared shortage of cash is not in the offing.
U.S. banks are not heavily exposed to the weaker European countries, Fed governor Daniel K. Tarullo said in testimony on Capitol Hill last week. Banks are in better shape overall, after fresh infusions of capital. Meanwhile, the U.S. economic recovery has been strengthening through the year, with jobs added in five of the last six months, and recent consumer spending and industrial output stronger than most forecasts.
But the fallout from Europe could still be widely felt. U.S. trade officials, hoping the country can dramatically boost its exports, are dismayed at the steep drop in the value of the euro -- which is around $1.25, down from more than $1.50 in November. The decline makes American goods more expensive compared with those produced in Europe. The slide in the common European currency could also change the way China and a host of Asian countries approach their currency policies, possibly making them less likely to agree with U.S. demands to raise the value of their money. If they raised it, Asian goods would become more expensive in world markets, making it easier for U.S. products to compete.
The connections are being closely watched. Analysts are studying how the involvement of Greek financial institutions in Eastern Europe, or Spanish banks in Latin America, could affect those economies. The International Monetary Fund and E.U. officials are doing biweekly checks on Greece's progress to ensure its economic reform program stays on track, according to Vassilis Kaskarelis, Greece's ambassador to the United States.
Inside the euro zone, banks are intimately linked, with a web of investments and cross-country bond holdings that could be a main vector for financial "contagion," with a default in one country weakening banks elsewhere.
There are some positive impacts in all this for the United States.
For one, uncertainty about European government debt has driven global investors toward U.S. government bonds, which in turn is pushing down long-term interest rates. The 10-year Treasury bond had a rate of 3.2 percent Friday compared with nearly 4 percent last month. Those lower rates should flow through to private borrowing, helping Americans getting mortgages or businesses looking to grow.
The European panic is also lowering the price of oil and other commodities on global markets, potentially making it cheaper for Americans to fuel their cars and heat their homes. A barrel of oil went for about $70 on Friday, down from almost $87 on April 6.
A final positive for the U.S. economy is that the stronger dollar will help keep inflation in check by reducing the cost of imports. That, combined with renewed worry about the strength of the recovery, is likely to give the Fed some leeway to delay raising interest rates above their current extremely low levels longer than it would have otherwise.
The most precise comparison is to the East Asian financial crisis that enveloped Thailand, Indonesia, South Korea and other nations in 1997 and 1998. There were widespread fears that the crisis would damage the U.S. economy, including through a financial contagion effect. The Fed even cut interest rates in the fall of 1998 to try to forestall a weakening in U.S. growth.
But there was little obvious impact on the U.S. economy, which grew 4.5 percent in 1997, 4.4 percent in 1998, and 4.8 percent in 1999.
Posted by Moss M.Jacques
Wall Street crash exposes world of stock market electronic trading
Published on 05-12-2010
In 10 bone-shaking minutes on Thursday the Dow Jones Industrial Average - representing the 30 most venerable US firms - briefly lost almost a tenth of its value.
Open-jawed investors blanched as the pensions and savings of millions of Americans were decimated, along with the livelihoods of countless more.
Days and a partial recovery later, the most fundamental question has still not been answered: What happened?
Concerns about Europe's debt crisis no doubt contributed, but few analysts believed worries about Greece's fiscal malfeasance - as serious as it may be - would cause US equities markets to go through a near-death experience.
The Securities and Exchange Commission, the New York Stock Exchange and even President Barack Obama have vowed to uncover the causes of the fall.
In the meantime, homespun theories have been shot down one-by-one.
The major US stock markets said a glitch on their trading platforms was not to blame.
Citigroup angrily brushed aside the notion that one of its traders had mistakenly hit the billion rather than million button on a sale.
Some bolder television commentators speculated that cyber-terrorism may be to blame, although evidence appeared to be lacking.
Whatever the trigger, blame for the severity of the crash is now aimed squarely at algorithmic trades.
At their simplest, "algos" are used to buy or sell shares at a certain trigger point, to limit losses or seek new profits.
They are responsible for anywhere between 60 and 90 per cent of trading on a normal day.
In a market that is driven by endless reams of data, algorithms are able to spot and act on opportunities at a speed investors could not hope to match.
"One program can trade thousands of stocks in milliseconds," explained Terrence Hendershott, a professor of finance at the University of California, Berkeley.
New figures for consumer spending or one stock's deviation from the broader price trend can trigger a rash of buying and selling while a human trader is off getting coffee.
But when the flow of data is disrupted or unusual, the effects can be dramatic.
Hendershott speculated that Thursday crash could have been caused by a badly programmed algorithm, or a trader's mistake.
That could have sparked automated selling that forced stock prices down and triggered a cascade of other automated sales. This domino effect could have occurred at such a pace that humans had no idea what was happening.
It is a scenario that proponents of algorithmic trading, like Hendershott, had thought improbable, until Thursday.
"What computers are particularly good at is processing the same information in the same ways and optimizing that very, very quickly," he said.
"What they might not be so good at is dealing with some new situations that have never occurred before."
The response from regulators and Congress has been swift. "A temporary one trillion drop in market value is an unacceptable consequence of a software glitch," said Senators Ted Kaufman and Mark Warner in a letter a colleagues.
A Congressional hearing is planned for Tuesday and calls are growing for regulation.
The Securities and Exchange Commission is urging exchanges to put better "speed bumps" in place that would slow down trade, turning more decisions back to human brokers.
Many on Wall Street see resolving the quandary as crucial to restoring the trust of ordinary investors.
"America's confidence in Wall Street was already low. It is now eroded even more than before," worried David Kotok of Cumberland Advisors - a financial firm.
But according to Hendershott, algorithms have also made markets more efficient, better able to assess the true value of an asset.
They were also responsible for the equally rapid recovery seen in stock markets on Thursday, he said, as programs spotted ultra-low prices for some stocks.
"It was bad that it went down so fast, but there was no way the humans were reacting fast enough to make it come back."
Thanks to algorithms, 10 minutes is now a very long time in the stock market.
Source: London Telegraph
Sunday, May 23, 2010
Posted by Moss M.Jacques
While the two bills are largely similar, there are key differences whose resolution could determine how tightly the reins on Wall Street will be pulled and how many safeguards are provided to consumers. For example, the Senate bill requires banks to divest their derivatives trading units and encourages regulators to prohibit banks from using their own capital for high-risk investments. The House bill doesn't. FINANCIAL REGULATION: House and Senate differences The Senate places a new consumer watchdog agency within the Federal Reserve. The House measure calls for a stand-alone entity but exempts car dealers - which lawmakers say sometimes steer buyers into bad loans - from agency oversight. The Senate bill provides for the orderly liquidation of failing financial firms but doesn't set aside a specific amount of money to pay for it. The House calls for a $150 billion fund, paid by assessments on financial institutions. "We expect (the conference) to be contentious," says Steve Adamske, spokesman for the House Financial Services Committee. Committee Chairman Barney Frank, D-Mass., will chair the conference committee, which will also feature Senate Banking Committee Chairman Chris Dodd, D-Conn., chief author of the Senate bill, and other members of committees with roles in financial regulation. All told, about 20 lawmakers from each of the chambers and both parties will participate, though the makeup will reflect the Democrats' majority. The conference is expected to begin after Memorial Day and last about two weeks. The legislation that emerges must then be passed again by the House and Senate. Frank and Dodd said Friday that they expect to present a final bill to President Obama by July 4. Frank also said he would like the conference to be televised, though that will be decided by the entire committee. Frank "wants to give the people the confidence that we are working to resolve the issues that led to taxpayer bailouts of the financial industry," Adamske says. Typically, the House passes stricter regulatory bills. But the Senate overhaul was toughened as public outrage boiled after the government filed fraud charges against Goldman Sachs last month. The House measure passed in December. As a result, Joe Lieber of Washington Analysis believes the final product "is likely to look more like the Senate bill. It's likely to be less moderated."
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
